How we rank hotels
The short version
Hotel rankings use published property information, dated rates and editorial judgement. Rates come from Booking.com, Expedia and hotels’ own sites. Guest scores are separate third party figures, not evidence that this site collects or analyses reviews at scale.
The source panels identify the available evidence and its limits. Hotel guides are research, not a claim of a personal stay.
The five criteria, and what each one weighs
- Room product 25%
- Room size, layout, privacy, condition, view and the difference between entry rooms and higher categories.
- Service 25%
- Patterns in verified guest feedback, service consistency, complaint handling and the practical support a hotel provides.
- Location 20%
- Access, setting, surrounding noise, transfer time and how well the position serves the reason for the trip.
- Food and beverage 15%
- Restaurant range, breakfast, consistency, published menus and recurring guest feedback on quality and price.
- Value 15%
- The live rate against the room, facilities, service and closest credible alternatives for the same dates.
The weights describe the editorial priorities. The repository does not contain a criterion scorecard for every hotel, so they are not presented as a reproducible numerical ranking formula.
An unexplained overall score is not a substitute for evidence. Editorial numeric scores are removed where their individual inputs and calculation are not published. Third party scores require a source and reading date.
Maker specifications are published facts, not measurements by LHC. No personal travel, testing or ownership experience is claimed under the house byline.
How a hotel gets into a guide
A guide compares properties for a particular trip. Location, the room category, facilities, published rates and one honest drawback inform the recommendation. The order is an editorial decision, not a paid placement.
Before a property can be written up it has to clear four practical tests.
One, only suitable property photographs
Only real photographs of the named property at 1200 pixels wide or more are used, with heroes at least 1600 pixels. Photographs are stored locally, never stock and never upscaled. If suitable photographs are unavailable an entry may show one photograph or none; one photograph has no carousel controls, and no photograph means no media block.
Two, sourced rates or an explicit unknown
A current sourced rate is shown where available, with the room category and reading date when recorded. Where no suitable quote exists the guide says Check rates rather than inventing a number. An update to copy does not automatically mean every rate was rechecked.
Three, a specific drawback
Each hotel recommendation should identify one specific drawback supported by its location, room category or published conditions.
Four, named evidence and its limits
Guest scores are retained only where the page identifies the service, source link and date read. This site does not claim to collect a large review dataset. A missing source is a limitation, not evidence of good service.
What disqualifies a hotel
An uncertain property identity, closure or contradictory source needs a correction. A shortage of suitable photographs is disclosed by leaving the entry without a media block rather than using another hotel’s image.
How rates are checked, and what to do with an old one
Rates are read from Booking.com, Expedia and hotels’ own sites. Some guides reuse explicitly dated price index data. Published package prices, estimates and historical suite prices must not be mistaken for current room quotes.
Use the reading date attached to a rate, not the page update date, to judge its age. Check rates for your own dates, occupancy, taxes, meal plan and cancellation terms. A guide update can correct text or photographs without obtaining a new price.
Why every property carries a drawback
A useful drawback names a specific issue: an inland location for a beach trip, a room category without the advertised pool, or a transfer that needs an extra connection. General praise does not replace that information.
Where the evidence is incomplete, the guide should say what is unknown rather than claim certainty.
Where our numbers come from
- Dated Booking.com, Expedia and official hotel rates.
- Third party guest scores only where a source link and date read are shown.
- Specifications published by each hotel.
- Public editorial coverage from named publications.
Use the reading date attached to a rate, not the page update date, to judge its age. Check rates for your own dates, occupancy, taxes, meal plan and cancellation terms. A guide update can correct text or photographs without obtaining a new price.
Desk research and its limits
All guides are desk research from maker specifications, operator policies and published rates. Sources and available check dates are listed on each page. Jack Williamson is a house pen name, not a claim of personal travel or product use.
We may earn a commission from Booking.com, Expedia, GetYourGuide, DiscoverCars, Airalo, Saily and Samsonite links; it never changes a ranking.
How we make money
The site uses affiliate links and has an editorial policy against paid ranking placement. The disclosure identifies the linked services; it is not a claim that every merchant pays the same commission.
Booking links depend on the visitor’s country. US and Canadian visitors use Booking.com through CJ where available; other visitors use Expedia through Travelpayouts where listed. Direct only hotels remain on their official sites, and hotels unavailable on Expedia retain the Booking.com path.
Commission revenue can vary by booking and provider. Independence is an editorial policy, not a mathematical consequence of equal payouts. Affiliate links are identified as sponsored and nofollow; official source citations are not affiliate links.
Who writes this, and the editorial standard
Jack Williamson is the openly labelled LHC house pen name for a one person site in Sydney. The about page explains the identity rather than presenting a fictional contributor or credentials.
The working standard is a direct answer, clear comparisons, published sources, visible FAQs, dated figures and explicit unknowns. Corrections are recorded publicly rather than disguised as new research.
Questions readers ask about trusting this site
Do hotels pay for a ranking position?
The editorial policy does not permit paid inclusion, position or removal. Affiliate commission is disclosed and is not a ranking criterion.
How is the site funded?
We may earn a commission from Booking.com, Expedia, GetYourGuide, DiscoverCars, Airalo, Saily and Samsonite links; it never changes a ranking.
Does a page update mean every price was rechecked?
No. A text or photograph correction can change the update date without a new price reading. Use the rate reading date and check your own dates before paying.
Does a hotel need five photographs to be included?
No. Only suitable real photographs of the named property at 1200 pixels wide or more are used, never stock or upscaled. Some entries show one photo or none.
Are hotel rankings claims of personal stays?
No. Hotel rankings are researched from published sources. All guides are desk research from maker specifications, operator policies and published rates, with sources and available check dates listed on each page.
Corrections
Read the corrections log · Send evidence
If something is wrong, send the evidence through the contact page. Accepted corrections are listed in the public corrections log.
How often this is reviewed
Use the reading date attached to a rate, not the page update date, to judge its age. Check rates for your own dates, occupancy, taxes, meal plan and cancellation terms. A guide update can correct text or photographs without obtaining a new price.